After Mauro Ongaro and Vince Pileggi introduced women's soccer to the Humber varsity lineup in 1996, it only took four seasons until Adriana Cataldo was named the first All-Canadian in program history.
OCAA and Humber Hall of Famer Joanna Vitale was the first and only three-time recipient in program history.
The CCAA All-Canadian award was introduced during the 1992-93 women's soccer season.
| Year | Athlete | Coach | Sport | Record |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Year: 1999 | Adriana Cataldo | Coach: Ongaro/Pileggi | Sport: Women's Soccer | Record: 8-1-1 |
| Year: 2001 | Adriana Cataldo | Coach: Ongaro/Pileggi | Sport: Women's Soccer | Record: 9-0-1 |
| Year: 2008 | Joanna Alexopulos | Coach: Ongaro/Pileggi | Sport: Women's Soccer | Record: 8-0-2 |
| Year: 2000 | Joanna Vitale | Coach: Ongaro/Pileggi | Sport: Women's Soccer | Record: 6-0-4 |
| Year: 2001 | Joanna Vitale | Coach: Ongaro/Pileggi | Sport: Women's Soccer | Record: 9-0-1 |
| Year: 2002 | Joanna Vitale | Coach: Ongaro/Pileggi | Sport: Women's Soccer | Record: 8-0-2 |
| Year: 2009 | Joanna Alexopulos | Coach: Ongaro/Pileggi | Sport: Women's Soccer | Record: 12-0-0 |
| Year: 2009 | Keyla Moreno | Coach: Ongaro/Pileggi | Sport: Women's Soccer | Record: 12-0-0 |
| Year: 2010 | Connie Tamburello | Coach: Ongaro/Pileggi | Sport: Women's Soccer | Record: 7-0-1 |
| Year: 2011 | Keyla Moreno | Coach: Ongaro/Pileggi | Sport: Women's Soccer | Record: 8-0-0 |
| Year: 2013 | Alora Walcott | Coach: Ongaro/Pileggi | Sport: Women's Soccer | Record: 5-1-2 |
| Year: 2022 | Kaitlynn Russell | Coach: Jose Caro | Sport: Women's Soccer | Record: 7-0-3 |
| Year: 2023 | Kaitlynn Russell | Coach: Jose Caro | Sport: Women's Soccer | Record: 7-0-3 |