Basketball - Men's (15)
| Year | Athlete | Coach | Sport | Record |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Year: 1984 | Doug McKinley | Coach: Mike Katz | Sport: Men's Basketball | Record: 19-5 |
| Year: 1987 | George McNeil | Coach: Mike Katz | Sport: Men's Basketball | Record: 18-2 |
| Year: 1988 | George McNeil | Coach: Mike Katz | Sport: Men's Basketball | Record: 15-3 |
| Year: 1989 | Earl Moncrieffe | Coach: Mike Katz | Sport: Men's Basketball | Record: 12-4 |
| Year: 1990 | Patrick Rhodd | Coach: Mike Katz | Sport: Men's Basketball | Record: 11-5 |
| Year: 1991 | Patrick Rhodd | Coach: Mike Katz | Sport: Men's Basketball | Record: 22-2 |
| Year: 1992 | Fitzroy Lightbody | Coach: Mike Katz | Sport: Men's Basketball | Record: 15-1 |
| Year: 1993 | Patrick Rhodd | Coach: Mike Katz | Sport: Men's Basketball | Record: 14-2 |
| Year: 1995 | Steve McGregor | Coach: Mike Katz | Sport: Men's Basketball | Record: 11-1 |
| Year: 1997 | Rowan Beckford | Coach: Mike Katz | Sport: Men's Basketball | Record: 5-5 |
| Year: 2001 | Cornell 'Jr.' Brown | Coach: Mike Katz | Sport: Men's Basketball | Record: 13-2 |
| Year: 2002 | Fitzroy Woolery | Coach: Mike Katz | Sport: Men's Basketball | Record: 10-5 |
| Year: 2004 | Shane Dennie | Coach: Mike Katz | Sport: Men's Basketball | Record: 12-3 |
| Year: 2022 | DeQuon Cascart | Coach: Omar Miles | Sport: Men's Basketball | Record: 9-0 |
| Year: 2024 | Jalen Menzies | Coach: Omar Miles | Sport: Men's Basketball | Record: 13-5 |