Soccer - Men's (24)
| Year | Athlete | Coach | Sport | Record |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Year: 1994 | Phil Caporrella | Coach: Germain Sanchez | Sport: | Record: 7-0-1 |
| Year: 1995 | Phil Caporrella | Coach: Germain Sanchez | Sport: | Record: 5-0-1 |
| Year: 1995 | Adam Morandini | Coach: Germain Sanchez | Sport: | Record: 5-0-1 |
| Year: 1996 | Luigi Della Rovere | Coach: Germain Sanchez | Sport: | Record: 5-1-0 |
| Year: 1996 | Adam Morandini | Coach: Germain Sanchez | Sport: | Record: 5-1-0 |
| Year: 1996 | Steve Spizzirri | Coach: Germain Sanchez | Sport: | Record: 5-1-0 |
| Year: 1997 | Luigi Della Rovere | Coach: Germain Sanchez | Sport: | Record: 5-1-0 |
| Year: 2000 | Jesse Calabro | Coach: Germain Sanchez | Sport: | Record: 8-1-1 |
| Year: 2001 | Mike Silva | Coach: Germain Sanchez | Sport: | Record: 10-0-2 |
| Year: 2002 | Matt Palleschi | Coach: Germain Sanchez | Sport: | Record: 8-1-3 |
| Year: 2004 | Kadian Lecky | Coach: Germain Sanchez | Sport: | Record: 8-0-0 |
| Year: 2005 | Kwame Osei | Coach: Germain Sanchez | Sport: | Record: 7-1-0 |
| Year: 2008 | Andrew DaSilva | Coach: Germain Sanchez | Sport: | Record: 9-3-0 |
| Year: 2009 | Andrew DaSilva | Coach: Germain Sanchez | Sport: | Record: 11-0-1 |
| Year: 2009 | Aleks Janjic | Coach: Germain Sanchez | Sport: | Record: 11-0-1 |
| Year: 2011 | Marcelo Capozzolo | Coach: Germain Sanchez | Sport: | Record: 7-0-1 |
| Year: 2013 | Mario Orestano | Coach: Michael Aquino | Sport: | Record: 6-1-1 |
| Year: 2015 | Jaineil Hoilett | Coach: Michael Aquino | Sport: | Record: 9-0-1 |
| Year: 2016 | Marcos Nunes | Coach: Michael Aquino | Sport: | Record: 10-0-0 |
| Year: 2017 | Kingsley Boasiako | Coach: Michael Aquino | Sport: | Record: 10-0-0 |
| Year: 2019 | Leaford Allen | Coach: Michael Aquino | Sport: | Record: 6-2-1 |
| Year: 2021 | Luca Gasparotto | Coach: Michael Aquino | Sport: | Record: 5-0-1 |
| Year: 2022 | Luca Uccello | Coach: Michael Aquino | Sport: | Record: 10-0-0 |
| Year: 2023 | Exosse Kadiebue | Coach: Michael Aquino | Sport: | Record: 7-1-2 |