After Eugene Selva was selected as the first CCAA All-Canadian in program history in 1997, Humber volleyball went on to earn four straight selections from 1998 to 2001. All eight selections came under the guidance of Hall of Fame coach Wayne Wilkins.
The CCAA All-Canadian award was introduced during the 1982-83 volleyball season.
| Year | Athlete | Coach | Sport | Record |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Year: 1997 | Eugene Selva | Coach: Wayne Wilkins | Sport: Men's Volleyball | Record: 11-3 |
| Year: 1998 | Tim Pennefather | Coach: Wayne Wilkins | Sport: Men's Volleyball | Record: 13-3 |
| Year: 1999 | Tim Pennefather | Coach: Wayne Wilkins | Sport: Men's Volleyball | Record: 16-1 |
| Year: 2000 | Matt Tim | Coach: Wayne Wilkins | Sport: Men's Volleyball | Record: 15-5 |
| Year: 2001 | Carter Walls | Coach: Wayne Wilkins | Sport: Men's Volleyball | Record: 15-3 |
| Year: 2010 | Terrel Bramwell | Coach: Wayne Wilkins | Sport: Men's Volleyball | Record: 19-4 |
| Year: 2012 | Terrel Bramwell | Coach: Wayne Wilkins | Sport: Men's Volleyball | Record: 23-1 |
| Year: 2020 | Jake Gomes | Coach: Wayne Wilkins | Sport: Men's Volleyball | Record: 23-1 |
| Year: 2022 | Joshua Fadare | Coach: Wayne Wilkins | Sport: Men's Volleyball | Record: 14-2 |
| Year: 2022 | Jake Gomes | Coach: Wayne Wilkins | Sport: Men's Volleyball | Record: 14-2 |